Home

Advertisement

Customize
 
 
15 August 2009 @ 02:40 pm
Wow, some people are obnoxious  
So I was reading a news article online that discussed, quite thoughtfully, the childfree lifestyle, and how childfree folk tend to be happier than some would think.
There was a veritable explosion of comments. Some of them opted to be truly obnoxious about it.
In 'The Case Against Having Kids', various reasons were given.
Some of the commenters disregarded these reasons entirely. They chose to interpret it as 'The Case Against Kids', and a personal affront to them.

Yes, we KNOW you love your kids. We of the childfree, however do not.

Do not treat us like monsters. Do not act like we are deviants. Having a child or not is a personal choice. People should respect it.

We are not 'selfish' just because we don't want to create offspring in our image, and we do not appreciate being dismissed as though 'oh well, if they can't see how their genes would affect the world, they wouldn't be good enough to reproduce anyway.'

Two drunken teenagers at a party can manage your frigging 'miracle of life', people. It takes conscious choice to look at the world and oneself and decide "No, I do not wish to be a parent".

So in the views of these people, we're either unnatural scum denying God's will blah blah blah letting down the country blah blah blah, or poor, misguided wretches who with enough nagging and peer pressure can be forced to conform, giving birth to little 'angels' who must then grow up with parents who never wanted or resent them, or even serious health conditions, because some childfree folk decide that they don't wish to saddle a child with painful debilitating hereditary diseases.

What's more selfish- saying we won't bring an unloved child into the world, or the people howling at us to do so, so that their lifestyle choice can be validated?

 
 
Current Location: At home
Current Mood: annoyed
 
 
( 5 comments — Post a new comment )
Jenny-fur Fangster: garfield: life's a bitch[info]lily_winterwood on August 15th, 2009 05:27 am (UTC)
...some people really don't get the idea that personal stuff are personal choices and it's a matter of personal opinion. Personal being the key term, too.

And we're really not short of humans on this planet right now, so no thanks.
Sedri: angry - Elphaba[info]sedri on August 15th, 2009 06:12 am (UTC)
I must agree. I want kids, but I can completely understand that some people don't, and anyone who tries to tell you what you should or should not do with your life is wrong to do so.
Lady Drace: otPEA[info]lady_drace on August 15th, 2009 08:53 am (UTC)
Hey, I love my son and I've always wanted kids. So I am probably happier with kids than without. But just because 'I' am happier with kids, certainly doesn't mean everybody else would be. I know several people IRL who have long ago made the choice of not having kids.

And it's not just for the sake of career or whatever. I can mention one person right here and now, who have chosen never to have kids, just because she doesn't want to. Period.

It's a consious choice and should be respected. And frankly, I think it's really unfair to the children born to parents who have kids just because "it's what you have to do" and not to parents who really want them.
Agent Tomato: Swamp Thing/Abby[info]agent_tomato on August 15th, 2009 03:16 pm (UTC)
Ugh. I personally want kids, but that's your own choice. No one has the right to condemn someone else's lifestyle.

People on both sides of every issue can be so horribly obnoxious about it...can't we all just decide to do what we think is best, and not try to convert everyone else to our point of view?
ornithoptercat[info]ornithoptercat on August 15th, 2009 03:27 pm (UTC)
My 'favorite' anti-child-free argument is "it's different when they're yours!". Yes, it is different. There's no one to take them the hell away from me when they won't STFU or I want a moment to myself. There's no one to pay the bills except me, and I'm in debt just supporting myself and going to school - and don't say "oh, the father", because right now there is no suitable father, and I'm not going to compromise on a life partner just because my biological clock is ticking. (Which it isn't anyway.)

There's also no one to take care of me and the baby when I inevitably become massively depressed because 1) have to be off meds to prevent birth defects 2) postpartum - almost guaranteed to hit after 4 bouts of normal depression 3) sleep deprivation 4) constant stress of being alone in the house with a screaming baby 5) guilt over NOT being ecstatic like the whole world thinks I should. You know those stories about people shaking infants to death? That'd be me. Not because I'm evil, but because I have a chronic mental illness that would be exacerbated LITERALLY five times over by the situation. If I really wanted a baby, I'd need a live-in caretaker for the first year and possibly a surrogate on top of it...or I could just adopt or NOT HAVE ONE at all.


I do, I admit, occasionally feel guilty/worried-for-humanity seeing all the absolute morons having multiple children on a generation length of under 20 years, while the most intelligent and educated portions of the populace have less-than-replacement-rate on a generation-length of 30ish. Not good longterm. But the need to improve the gene pool really just makes me want to pour in chlorine, not add one drop of clean water, and I'm not sure the asthma and depression don't make the water just as bad as the dumb does.
 
 

Advertisement

Customize